From the Department of "I question the timing", Mark Tapscott at LifeZette has DOJ Springs Surprise Weekend Release of FBI Scandal Docs - Heavy deletions render the materials extremely difficult to translate fully, but multiple passages offer important insights, clues and Scott Johnson at Powerline has Saturday night document dump:
Charlie Savage’s New York Times article draws no inferences from the timing. I say the Saturday night document dump resets best scandal management practices. These documents were not released on Saturday night because the FBI and the Department of Justice are proud of themselves for what they reveal.Also from Tapscott: Fitton Calls FBI’s FISA Application a ‘Self-Licking Ice Cream Cone’ - Judicial Watch chief points to multiple circular justifications that show Russia collusion narrative was manufactured by Trump's opponents
“Self-licking ice cream cone. FISA docs cite Clinton-DNC Dossier, leak of Dossier to media, and leak of Dossier info through Dem Senator Harry Reid. Corrupt dishonesty to get court approval to spy on @RealDonaldTrump team,” Fitton tweeted Sunday concerning the 421 pages of FISA application-related documents DOJ made public late Saturday.Roger Kimball at PJ Media, It’s Oakland in Muellerville
The phrase a “self-licking ice cream cone” refers to “a self-perpetuating system that has no purpose other than to sustain itself.
I liked what the great Tom Fitton of Judicial Watch had to say about the heavily redacted 400-page DOJ document dump regarding the FISA warrant to spy on Carter Page. It is, he said, a “self-licking ice cream cone.” The image is appropriately surreal. But the more I think about it, the more I think it is only partially applicable to the whole RussiaGate melodrama we’ve been witnessing for the last year and a half.Stacy McCain also notes the circularity: The Carter Page FISA Documents: The Steele Dossier, the Leaks, the Witch Hunt
Wikipedia defines this autogleipsimous activity as “a self-perpetuating system that has no purpose other than to sustain itself.” The Mueller investigation and its attendant pseudo-pods in the media and “intelligence community” are indeed self-perpetuating. But they exhibit a purpose that goes far beyond their own self-perpetuation.
No, in this safari, big game is the object, the end, the purpose, to wit: the destruction of the president of the United States.
Here are some headlines from September and October 2016:
All of these articles, published in the closing weeks of the 2016 presidential campaign, were the result of (a) the infamous Steele dossier, created for Fusion GPS under contract with Democrats, and (b) unauthorized leaks from within the FBI and other federal agencies. We know that senior FBI officials were biased against Donald Trump, that the Mueller investigation has made no charges of wrongdoing by Carter Page, and that “Source #1” for getting a FISA warrant for surveillance of Page was the Steele dossier:U.S. intel officials probe ties between Trump adviser and Kremlin — Michael Isikoff, Yahoo News, Sept. 23, 2016Michael Isikoff has the latest tale of people with questionable ties to Russia within the Trump campaign — Washington Post, Sept. 23, Sept. 23, 2016Donald Trump advisor meetings with Russian officials being investigated — New York Daily News, Sept. 23, 2016U.S. Officials Probe Ties Between Trump Adviser and Russia — CNN, Sept. 26, 2016Who is Carter Page? — Politico, Oct. 6, 2016Investigating Donald Trump, F.B.I. Sees No Clear Link to Russia — New York Times, Oct. 31, 2016
. . .
The Steele dossier and media leaks were the only basis for this surveillance, so far as we know, and more than a year into Mueller’s investigation, there has been zero evidence of wrongdoing by Page.
All of this indicates that the Obama administration wrongly targeted a U.S. citizen for surveillance, in service to a partisan effort to discredit the Republican presidential candidate, by giving a semblance of official credibility to the Steele dossier that Democrats paid for. Note that the liberal media were willing participants in all this, repeatedly publicizing the federal “probe” of the “Trump adviser” and his Russian “ties.”
This is the real “Russian collusion” scandal — the Deep State colluding with the “fake news” media in an effort to help Hillary Clinton win and, when that failed, working to sabotage Trump’s administration by creating the appearance that his victory was illegitimate.
On the newly-released Carter Page FISA wiretap application: There are many blacked-out paragraphs and pages. I don't know what is in them. That said, here, from the unredacted portions, is the dog's breakfast of a case the FBI made for wiretapping Page: 1/14— Byron York (@ByronYork) July 22, 2018
Even more Tapscott: This FISA Passage Points to the Heart of Mueller’s Collusion Case Against Trump - FBI officials contend Carter Page allegedly influenced the president and the Republican Party to go easy on Russia in Ukraine and points out that the FBI seems to be concerned that "Candidate #1" might change policy on the USSR and Ukraine. That ain't your business, boys.
Ann Alhouse:"Carter Page on Sunday called the accusations against him detailed in the foreign surveillance warrant application released by the FBI 'so ridiculous.'"
"'You talk about misleading the courts, it's just so misleading... It's literally a complete joke.'"Byron York works his way through the Nunes memo paragraph by paragraph and confirms that the FISA warrant application supports Nunes memo, while John Hideracker at Powerline notes how The Associated Press Lies About the FISA Application. Why would you expect better?
CNN reports on the interview that was on CNN's "State of the Union."
I have not attempted to read the long document that was released, but one of the commenters in last night café, Yancey Ward, did:
. . .
I don't have the patience to read the thing myself, but that shows why government officials may chose to write long, evasive documents. Let me know if there's anything about Yancey Ward's description that you think is wrong and tell me exactly why. And don't be verbose! I'm suspicious of verbosity. It makes me feel that you are hiding something.
The AP seems to suggest that there is some inconsistency between Page’s denial of being an “agent of a foreign power” and his claim, back in 2013, to be an “informal adviser” to certain Russians. Any such suggestion is entirely false.Kathryn Blackhurst at Lifezette: FBI Blew ‘Really Good Opportunity’ for FISA Warrant Transparency, Gowdy Says - 'We'll never know whether' the bureau 'had enough' info 'without the dossier' to surveil Carter Page
The phrase “agent of a foreign power” has a specific meaning. It is defined at 50 U.S.C. §1801(b)(2)(E). An “agent of a foreign power” is one who “knowingly aids or abets any person,” or “knowingly conspires with any person,” to “[engage] in clandestine intelligence gathering activities for or on behalf of a foreign power,” or “pursuant to the direction of an intelligence service or network of a foreign power, knowingly [engage] in any other clandestine intelligence activities for or on behalf of such foreign power, which activities involve or are about to involve a violation of the criminal statutes of the United States,” or “knowingly [engage] in sabotage or international terrorism, or activities that are in preparation therefor, for or on behalf of a foreign power.”
Obviously, these are serious charges. In its FISA application, the FBI expressed confidence that Carter Page was an “agent of a foreign power.” But he wasn’t. We know that for certain, because if there were even even the faintest hint of evidence after months of Democratic Party surveillance, Bob Mueller would have charged him. Carter Page is innocent, and the FBI’s assurances to the FISA court were false. You would never learn this from the AP’s biased account, however.
“We’ll never know whether or not the FBI had enough without the dossier — the unvetted dossier — because they included it, and everyone who reads this [Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act] application sees the amount of reliance they placed on this product funded by Hillary Clinton’s campaign and the DNC,” Gowdy said.More Gowdy care of Allahpundit Trey Gowdy: If There Was Any Evidence That Trump Colluded, Adam Schiff Would Have Leaked It Already Self evident.
. . .
“The other thing I hope my fellow citizens will take note of is the FBI missed a really good opportunity to tell the judge exactly who paid for that,” Gowdy said, pointing to a footnote in the warrant application. “If you look at the footnote, it takes a lot more effort to define it the way they did, where you have no idea who funded it, than just to come right out and say the DNC hired Perkins Coie, who hired Fusion GPS. who hired Christopher Steele.”
Among the positions he took this morning in “Fox News Sunday,” in no particular order:Eli Okun at Politico": Graham: Carter Page wiretap ‘not at all’ justified, Should Somebody Hire Carter Page A Lawyer? The Last Tradition: Trump says looking more and more like his campaign was 'illegally being spied upon', new documents released on Saturday and Sometimes Memes Explain Russiagate Better Than Words. One of several:
- Once you’ve seen the evidence, you know there’s not a shadow of a doubt that Russia interfered in 2016
- If Trump won’t listen to his natsec people about that, maybe they should resign(!)
- It’s possible to think Russia did wrong but that Trump was legitimately elected
- The FBI’s FISA warrant application against Carter Page is tainted by the fact that it didn’t specify that the dossier was paid for by Team Clinton
- Peter Strzok is a weasel whose own texts prove that he was actively looking to take down Trump, and Comey’s recent cheering for Democrats only makes it worse
- Russia’s crime in 2016 was a crime against all Americans, not just Democrats
Andrew McCarthy Shocked FISA Application Used As Evidence To Spy On Carter
Roger Simon at PJ Media The FBI Goes Full Nixon with FISA Report
I wonder if the people in FBI leadership -- trapped in their own feedback loop -- really understand what damage they have done to the organization's reputation in the country at large. It's close to irreversible. Or perhaps they don't care, as long as they get their man -- Trump, obviously, not Carter Page, the small fry of small fries. (The news that Mueller was immunizing Tony Podesta to rat on Manafort just about put the capper on the whole thing.)Why is Mueller handing off key cases? by Byron York at the WaEx:
What is going on? I asked a few former federal prosecutors if they saw any messages in Mueller's move. The takeaway: These aren't encouraging developments for those longing for a big collusion/conspiracy/coordination indictment from Mueller.Katelyn Polantz, CNN: How long will Mueller's investigation go on? As long as it takes to get Trump on something, anything. At least that seems to be CNN's view. "Tyler Durnden" at Zero Hedge notices the same players in a different game: FBI Probe Into Russian Uranium Bribes Concealed By Obama DOJ; Mueller, McCabe, Rosenstein Involved. Michael Ledeen at PJ Media: Why Are the Democrats and the Spooks Suddenly so Ferociously Anti-Putin? One can almost always ascribe Democrat behavior to psychological projection. Because they did it, they're sure you will too. Politico: Rand Paul to ask Trump to revoke security clearance of ex-CIA chief Brennan About time. Willis L. Krumholz at the Federalist: At Helsinki, Trump Undermined Our Power-Abusing Intelligence Agencies, Not America. True dat.
"I think it proves that little if any of what Mueller's team has generated so far is linked to the special counsel's mandate," said Former Prosecutor 1. "Everything that is public so far could, should and typically is handled by either United States Attorney offices of jurisdiction; National Security Division attorneys, or even Criminal Division attorneys at Main Justice."
"I think Mueller doesn't have anything on collusion," said Former Prosecutor 2. "I think we would have seen it. I don't see anything that looks like there's a crime lurking — maybe he's got eight indictments under seal, but to me, it makes no sense. All of this says to me there is no there there."
Via PJ Media's Live Blog: --->Clapper: Obama Was Behind The Whole Thing, Excellent read: FISA warrant application supports Nunes memo, Fool. Rubio pushes back on Trump's claims his campaign was spied on illegally: Investigators 'didn't do anything wrong', Page: I've never been an agent of a foreign power, Carter Page was 'more like Inspector Gadget than Jason Bourne,' Gowdy says amid FISA release, Indeed. Rep. Bob Goodlatte: Page FISA documents show serious FBI problems, House Judiciary Chairman: We Want John Brennan To Testify, FBI told FISA court Steele wasn't source of report used to justify surveilling Trump team, docs show,
She sure got around Alleged Russian agent Maria Butina met with Obama administration officials in 2015, new report says and she isn't even that hot.