Thursday, December 11, 2014

Obamacare Schadenfreude: Post Grubernol Drip

There are, of course, still news articles coming out of the Grubernol's greats Tuesday hearings:

I Do Not Think That Word Means What Gruber Thinks It Means
by Smitty, Via Hot Air, emphasis mine:
In an appearance on Capitol Hill on Tuesday, Gruber was probed by Rep. Mike Turner (R-OH) over his lamentation that the administration’s lack of honesty about the imposition of taxes both on those who do not purchase insurance and on those who do have insurance. Turner prodded Gruber over whether he had any conversations with members of the White House who perhaps shared his opinion that the ACA needed to be crafted in a “tortured” way to ensure its passage.
After much deliberation, Gruber finally answered: “I honestly do not recall.”
The Fatal Conceit of Jonathan Gruber

Gruber came to my attention more than two years ago. As a scholar of Soviet planning, I was struck by its parallels with ObamaCare. I read the New York Times’ glowing reports about its architect, one Jonathan Gruber of MIT. The New York Times’ “Mr. Health Care Mandate”of March 29, 2012 was an ode to genius economics professor cum scientific planner, Gruber. After the Supreme Court’s tough questioning of the ObamaCare legislation, the Times probably felt that ObamaCare needed a boost from Gruber, who, by his own admission, “knows more about this law than any other economist.” It was to Professor Gruber that the White House turned to design its new health care law, and for good reason.

The Times reassuringly described Gruber as “the numbers wizard at MIT,” who has “spent decades modeling the intricacies of the health care ecosystem.” Gruber has “brought a level of science to an issue that would otherwise be just opinion.”

I might note that the Soviets used the term “science” for their own “scientific” planning commission. I drew little comfort from Professor Gruber’s scientific-planning credentials, especially when I learned “he’s the only person you can go to for that kind of thing.” Gruber, aided by his brilliant MIT graduate student assistants, is a one-man Gosplan, the name given to the Soviet Union’s state planning committee. That is not much of a recommendation. Science is better served by competing ideas not by a one-person monopoly.

Both Gruber and the USSR’s Gosplan planners believe their planning is “scientific” and executed by “the best of the best.” Both types of planning commissars suffer from F. A. Hayek’s “fatal conceit”—the belief that we can plan incredibly complex economic systems. As Hayek pointed out in his writings, such “scientific” plans inevitably fall apart under the weight of unintended consequences. . .
Maybe it’s a blessing in disguise most of the press ignored Gruber’s comments
It seems that there is only so much the mainstream political press can ignore. In the wake of Tuesday’s congressional hearing in which health care policy expert Jonathan Gruber attempted to explain his inflammatory comments about the law and the easily misled American voter, those media outlets that were still maintaining an embargo on that story finally gave up the ghost.

Tuesday’s hearings were informative primarily for what Gruber was not willing to say. The health policy consultant succumbed to amnesia when he was pressed to recall if he ever had a conversation with a member of the administration who shared his belief that the ACA’s construction was “tortured” so as to get the bill passed by Congress. He refused to surrender documents relating to his work with the government, and played coy to the point where he attempted to debate the definition of the word “document” with Rep. Jason Chaffetz (R-UT). This was newsworthy stuff, but the primary focus of the mainstream press was on Gruber’s dubious and abundant apologies for insensitive comments that much of the public heard for the first time only last night. . .
Trey Gowdy Eviscerates Sniveling Worm Jonathan Gruber
No wonder the Democrats released their partisan CIA “torture” report today. Anything to distract the American people from seeing the carnage of Jonathan Gruber testifying before Congress.

Needless to day, South Carolina’s Trey Gowdy stole the show as he reduced Gruber to a pile of mush. . .


One gets the sense that Dr. Jon learned how how to grovel before school yard bullies years ago.

Obamacare Advisor Who Called Voters 'Stupid' to Congress: 'I Have No Philosophy of Abortion, End-of-Life Care'
"If there are fewer elderly people, particularly poor elderly people, wouldn't that save a ton of money too? ... And do you understand the dangerous implications of going down this path?" Massie asked.

"I have no philosophy of abortion. I have no philosophy of end-of-life care," Gruber answered. "My job as an economist is to deliver the empirical facts so that you all can make the necessary decisions."

Pressing further, Massie asked Gruber if he advocates the rationing of end-of-life care, and "as an economist, does it save money?"

"I do not advocate that the federal government should ration end-of-life care," Gruber answered.
"Vunce der rockets are up, who cares vere zeh come dow? Dat's not my department" say Werner von Braun.

In non-Gruber Obamacare Schadenfreude, soon to be ex-Senate majority leader Harry Reid is joining the chorus of democrats regretting how Obamacare has cost them their leaderships: Harry Reid: 'We Never Recovered from the Rollout' of Obamacare
As he tells a New York Times reporter:
In hindsight, Mr. Reid said, it was easier to see how damaging the mismanaged rollout of the Affordable Care Act exchanges had been. “We never recovered from the rollout because the election became one that was directed toward the president. We couldn’t overcome that,” he said. Still, he added, “I should have seen it coming.”
This follows Chuck Schumer, another leading Senate Democrat, who criticized Obamacare recently, too
Sebelius has figured out why Obamacare is unpopular: The ‘Obama’ part

Former Health and Human Services Sec. Kathleen Sebelius is back, and she has figured out why the Affordable Care Act is so unpopular.

No, it’s not the law’s imposition of new taxes on those who have health insurance, or the “fines” levied on individuals who are now forced to purchase insurance whether they want it or not. It’s not the limits the law places on access to preferred health care providers. It’s not the fact that millions in the individual market lost the plans with which they were happy with but did not comport with new ACA coverage standards, nor the fact that millions more are set to lose their policies when the law is eventually fully implemented. It’s not the law’s deleterious impact on the labor participation rate, which remains at its lowest point since the Carter administration.

Nope. The reason why “Obamacare” is so persistently unpopular is the fact that the law bears the name of a president who is also unpopular.

“I think we may need to call it something in the future different, but it is working,” Sebelius said at an event sponsored by Politico. “Obamacare, no question, has a very bad brand that has been driven intentionally by a lot of misinformation and a lot of paid advertising.”

Maybe it’s the sudden onset of “Gruber syndrome” that prompted Sebelius to suggest the public has been led by the nose by disreputable propagandists and only views the law unfavorably because they lack the cognitive abilities to think for themselves. Maybe the ACA covers that as a preexisting condition.
Well, at least she didn't say it was because he was negro black African American. Which puts her a step above most of the democrats in congress.

Obamacare is slowing the rise of health care spending! Well, not so much
While the news cycle continues to explode over big ticket items, the New York Post notices that the administration has been feeding some bits of “good news” out into the media stream. One of these is yet more proof that, all evidence to the contrary, Obamacare is working out just fine, thank you very much. And one indicator of this is that the program is clearly slowing the rise of health care spending in the United States. That’s a win, right? Well, it would be if it were true.
The ObamaCare lies keep coming. In two highly publicized announcements last week, top Obama health officials claimed the Affordable Care Act is slowing health care spending and improving hospital safety.
The media parroted these boasts, but the evidence shows they’re bogus.
Even as administration figures — from President Obama down — distance themselves from Jonathan Gruber, the ObamaCare adviser caught calling the public stupid, they’re still relying on his playbook: They assume we’re not going to check their facts.
On Dec. 3, federal actuaries released data showing that health spending inched up only 3.6 percent in 2013.
As the report notes, health care spending actually began to slow in 2009, and it wasn’t because of any great shift in government programs. It came about because the economy had tanked, people had a lot less money to spend and they began putting off doctor visits and medical procedures or medicines which they simply couldn’t afford. That downward pressure continued for years without comment by the administration until they needed a convenient data point to shore up the public messaging campaign.
And Job health insurance costs rising faster than wages
People with insurance through an employer—that is, most people with health coverage—are paying "more in premiums and deductibles than ever before" as those costs outpace the growth of wages, a new reportfinds.

Total premiums for covering a family through an employer-based plan rose 73 percent from 2003 through 2013, while workers' personal share of those premium costs leaped 93 percent during the same time frame, the Commonwealth Fund report said. At the same time, median family income grew just a measly 16 percent.
. . .
However, Collins noted, Obamacare also contains some inflationary drivers for employer-based health plans, including the rule allowing adults below the age of 26 to remain on their parents' plans, and the provision that requires plans to cover the costs of preventative health services such as birth control without requiring any co-payment.

"Despite those changes," she said, "we're seeing an overall leveling off in the rate of growth of premiums."

"But because incomes have grown so slowly, you still have an [insurance cost] growth rate ahead of income," Collins said.
The Obama "no-growth" economy is killing any benefits from Obamacare. But at least the people who never went back to work because of his policies can get subsidized health insurance.

Feds Plan for 35 Agencies to Help Collect, Share, Use Electronic Health Info
Along with the primary goal of expanding the availability of health insurance, the Affordable Care Act aims to make the use of Electronic Health Records (EHR) universal. This plan actually began with the 2009 stimulus (the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act), which included the Health Information Technology for Economic and Clinical Health (HITECH) Act. Doctors and other health providers have been offered incentives to convert patient information and health histories to a compatible and transferable electronic format, and as of June 2014, 75 percent of eligible doctors and 92 percent of eligible hospitals had received payments under the program.

This week, the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) announced the release of the Federal Health IT Strategic Plan 2015-2020, which details the efforts of some 35 departments and agencies of the federal government and their roles in the plan to "advance the collection, sharing, and use of electronic health information to improve health care, individual and community health, and research."
So who's worried about the NSA when 35 different agencies will be "sharing" your personal information?

All Senate GOP staff going on ObamaCare
Senate Republican staffers will be required to obtain health insurance through ObamaCare's exchanges under a rule passed Wednesday by the GOP Conference.

The proposal from Sen. David Vitter (R-La.) means that Senate Republicans will designate their staff as "official," moving them automatically onto the marketplaces.

A loophole used in both chambers allows lawmakers to designate staff as "unofficial" or "official staff," which permits them to keep their insurance coverage under the Federal Employee Health Benefits Program.

"Republican senators made a strong, principled statement today in passing my resolution," Vitter said in a statement.

"Washington should have to live under ObamaCare just like everybody else until we repeal it. And we won't be complicit in Obama's illegal rule designed to protect Washington insiders."

Vitter is an outspoken critic of some lawmakers' decision to keep their staff off the marketplaces.

He also opposes the employer subsidy for insurance given to lawmakers and staff by the government, arguing it gives Congress an unfair advantage. The question of whether staffers will still receive financial help to pay for their coverage was not addressed in Wednesday's resolution.

The GOP Conference challenged Senate Democrats to adopt a similar policy and not allow their aides to remain on the Federal Employee Health Benefits Program.
From Alinsky's Rules for Radicals:
RULE 4: “Make the enemy live up to its own book of rules.” If the rule is that every letter gets a reply, send 30,000 letters. You can kill them with this because no one can possibly obey all of their own rules. 

Jingle Boo... er Bells



That must take a lot of practice. Don't miss the B-Side. Wombat-socho has the original Rule 5 post "Rule 5 Sunday: Relay Breakdown" ready at The Other McCain.

Ships with Lasers



Now I know what I want for Christmas. . .

Wednesday, December 10, 2014

Are Chesapeake Bay Sturgeon on the Way Back

Atlantic sturgeon back in Bay, or did they ever leave?
Thought nearly extinct in the Chesapeake just two decades ago, sturgeon are turning up in surprising numbers and in surprising places. They’re also doing surprising things, like spawning in the fall — unlike any other anadromous fish on the East Coast.

Much of what was common knowledge 20 years ago is being cast aside as discoveries come at an increasingly rapid pace. “What we would have said a year ago about sturgeon, we wouldn’t say today,” said Chris Hager, a biologist which Chesapeake Scientific, a consulting firm, who has studied the big fish for more than a decade.
Not a Chesapeake Sturgeon
Every now and then, fisherman hook something really monstrous that the are unable to land. Sturgeon are on the short list of suspects.

A few years ago, most biologists would have said that only the James River had a reliable, if small, breeding population. Now, some think the James alone holds a population that could number in the thousands. Next door in the Pamunkey, scientists last year documented a spawning population.

This year, Maryland biologists caught eight ready-to-spawn fish in Marshyhope Creek on the Eastern Shore. “And if you go by what the fishermen are telling us, there’s a lot more of them out there,” said Chuck Stence, a fisheries biologist with the Maryland Department of Natural Resources.
Actual Chesapeake Bay Sturgeon
 I wonder if the watermen have started poaching them yet?

Jumping sturgeon have been reported in the Mattaponi which, like the Pamunkey, is a York River tributary. In Maryland, jumping sturgeon were reported in the Nanticoke River, upstream of its confluence with the Marshyhope.

Biologists expect to expand their sturgeon searches into those rivers next year. And they tick off other rivers they consider candidates for hidden sturgeon populations: the Rappahannock, the Potomac, maybe even the Choptank and Chester.

“If they are up in the Pamunkey, they can be anywhere,” Hager said. “They are not going to be everywhere, but you are going to have to explore it, and I think that is going to continue to go on for quite some time.”
I look forward to being able to catch and release my first Chesapeake Bay Sturgeon.

Wombat's Wednesday News Fodder


A brief saunter through the news, using Wombat-socho's "Live at FiveSix: 12.10.14" as a starting point."

Contrasting Claims Of Torture Effectiveness From Senate, CIA: Intelligence committee claims intel was available elsewhere without torture.
Thirteen techniques used by interrogatorsMcCain-supported report says brutal tactics didn’t workJohn Yoo: A torture report for the dustbinJohn McLaughlin: Senate interrogation report distorts the CIA’s success at foiling terrorist plots
So three really bad people were water boarded and five given enemas and thousands of American lives were probably saved? I'm OK with that.

Massive $1.1 Trillion Continuing Resolution Unveiled: Something to piss off both the Tea Party and the Democrats - Meanwhile, the Titanic continued on course toward the iceberg.

Berkeley Protesters March For Fourth Straight Night: Highway blocked, stores vandalized - Put a fence around the city cut off the power, and don't let anyone in or out for a week. Call it time out for having a temper tantrum.

Olivia Wilde Looking Fit! Pics from Hawaii vacation with hubby Jason Sudeikis. - You do realize this is just an excuse to post at picture of her, don't you? Just like the media.


IRS Paid $6 Billion In Bogus Child Tax Credits - And yet they devoted an entire division to taking down the Tea Party. But then, it never was about the allegedly lost revenue, was it?

Colorado Weed Taxes Rebound After First Dip
The Colorado Department of Revenue says the state brought in about $3.2 million from recreational marijuana sales in October. That's up from about $2.9 million in September but below the roughly $3.3 million of recreational pot sales taxes in August.

Marijuana retailers say they are expecting sales to pick up this fall and winter along with ski travel. A Colorado analysis released in July estimated that 90 percent of recreational pot sales in mountain resort towns are made to out-of-state visitors.
I think all the Indian reservations need to "legalize" pot for the revenue, and give Colorada a run for their green pot-tourist bucks.


How To Search For Old Facebook Posts - I can't think of one I'd want to find, but I suppose someone somewhere can.

Maria Shriver Doesn’t Like Her Son Dating Miley Cyrus - I don't see the problem. If he doesn't like her later, he can just drop her at the bottom of some convenient Massachusetts tidal pool. But I just can't imagine why she wouldn't want her in the family.

Michelle Malkin: Welcome To TotCare – Obama’s Preschool Takeover
On Wednesday, the White House Summit on Early Education will unveil nearly $1 billion in new “investments” to “expand access to high-quality early childhood education to every child in America” from “birth and continuing to age 5.” It’s a retread of President Obama’s 2013 State of the Union school-spending plan, which was a repackaging of his 2011 Race to the Top Early Learning Challenge program.

Those Obama initiatives are knockoffs of moldy-old Democratic policy chestnuts, such as former Vice President Al Gore’s push to fund preschool for all 3-year-olds at a cost to taxpayers of at least $50 billion over 10 years, left-wing actor/director Rob Reiner’s “I Am Your Child” campaign for universal preschool and child care, and Hillary Clinton’s various “It Takes a Village” schemes to expand Head Start from womb to work. With age comes fiefdom.
Give me a child until he is seven and I will give you the man the next generation of liberals".  

Megan McArdle: You Can’t Just Accuse People Of Rape - Shockingly, as reasonable discussion of the trade off between assuming all rape reports are credible, and assuming all rape reports are false until proven, from a woman who knows her stats.

Wombat-socho has the original Rule 5 post "Rule 5 Sunday: Relay Breakdown" ready at The Other McCain.

Obamacare Schadenfreude: The Grand Grubernol

Le Théâtre du Grand-Guignol (French pronunciation: ​[ɡʁɑ̃ ɡiɲɔl]: "The Theatre of the Big Puppet") – known as the Grand Guignol – was a theatre in the Pigalle area of Paris (at 20 bis, rue Chaptal). From its opening in 1897 until its closing in 1962, it specialised in naturalistic horror shows. Its name is often used as a general term for graphic, amoral horror entertainment, a genre popular from Elizabethan and Jacobean theatre (for instance Shakespeare's Titus Andronicus, and Webster's The Duchess of Malfi and The White Devil), to today's splatter films.
Yesterday, Dr. Jonathon Gruber, professor of MIT, who sometime called himself the architect of Obamacare, seated next to Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services Administrator Marilyn Tavenner testified before Darryl Issa's House Oversight Committee.  In his opening statement he dismissed his role as the architect of the plan, and did his best to abase himself with apologies to the people he insulted, the American public:
Beleaguered Obamacare adviser Jonathan Gruber declared he was not “the architect” of the health law as House Republicans on Tuesday hit hard at a pair of scandals that have overshadowed an otherwise successful launch of the second sign-up season.

“I was not the ‘architect’ of President [Barack] Obama’s health care plan,” the Massachusetts Institute of Technology economist told the House Oversight committee. He repeatedly apologized and dismissed as “mean,” “glib” and “arrogant” a series of controversial remarks about the passage of Obamacare and the “stupidity” of the American voter.

“I am not a political adviser nor a politician,” said Gruber, who was a key economic adviser during the drafting of the law. And in his most pointed mea culpa, he allowed: “It was inexcusable that I tried to appear smarter by insulting others.”
However, he lawyered up regarding the  amount of money he has made during the creation of Obamacare: Gruber Refuses to Tell Congress Amount Gov’t Paid Him for Obamacare
GOP Oversight chairman Darrel Issa informed Gruber that due to a misfiled form, the committee did not receive the complete compensation data for his work on Obamacare. “Would you agree to supplement your Exhibit B, so that we would have . . . your state revenue that you would’ve also received, since ultimately it’s Affordable Care Act-related?” he asked.

“I’m sure my counsel would be happy to take that up with you,” Gruber replied, deferring to his lawyer.

“Actually I was asking would you agree to provide it,” Issa said, prompting Gruber to speak with his counsel before again refusing to answer.

“Why doesn’t he just tell us?” interjected Ohio Republican Jim Jordan. “How much money did you get from the state taxpayers and the federal taxpayers? He’s under oath, why doesn’t he tell us how much he got paid by the taxpayers? We don’t have to wait for him to send something to us, he should just be able to tell us.”

Jordan later pressed Gruber on the question again, but the professor refused to comply. “As I said, the committee could take that up with my counsel,” he repeated.
He also declined to give the committee any of the results he produced using government funds: Talk to my lawyer: Gruber won’t commit to turning over documents he produced for ObamaCare.



Any documents he produced for the US government should be available via FOIA. At least that was my understanding when I was getting grants.

Not exactly an indication that he has nothing to hide.

He also suffered some of the expected memory lapses regarding his contacts with the White House:
Gruber won’t deny the White House wanted to trick Congress into passing the ACA
In an appearance on Capitol Hill on Tuesday, Gruber was probed by Rep. Mike Turner (R-OH) over his lamentation that the administration’s lack of honesty about the imposition of taxes both on those who do not purchase insurance and on those who do have insurance. Turner prodded Gruber over whether he had any conversations with members of the White House who perhaps shared his opinion that the ACA needed to be crafted in a “tortured” way to ensure its passage.

After much deliberation, Gruber finally answered: “I honestly do not recall.”

For those keeping track, that is not a “no.”

It defies logic, and insults just as much as did Gruber’s original comments about the “stupidity of the American voter,” to presume that the administration did not take some part in the “tortured” way in which Obamacare was crafted.
He also tried a remarkably stupid gambit to walk back his comments regarding the application of subsidies to state vs. federal marketplaces, which previously suggested that the law was designed to deny subsidies to states that did not join the party: Jonathan Gruber’s Weak New Excuse for His Obamacare Exchange Subsidies “Speak-O”
When this remark initially surfaced over the summer, Gruber described it as a "speak-o," the verbal equivalent of a typo. But that was hard to believe given that Gruber elaborated on it at length, and given that another recorded remarked quickly surfaced in which Gruber said almost exactly the same thing. The recordings strongly suggested that he meant to say what he said, and that he knew what the implications were.

In today’s testimony, Gruber offered a new explanation, saying that what he meant when he made the remarks in 2012 was that he wasn’t confident the federal government would set up an exchange; if the federal government didn’t build a fallback, then that would mean that states choosing not to build their own would lose access to tax credits. In the prepared version of his testimony, he puts it like this: "The point I believe I was making was about the possibility that the federal government, for whatever reason, might not create a federal exchange."

For several reasons, it’s difficult to buy this updated explanation. For one thing, it conveniently ignores the question Gruber was asked in that January 2012 presentation, which was about the establishment of exchanges. "It is my understanding that if states don’t provide them," the questioner says, "then the federal government will provide them for the states."

In his response, Gruber doesn’t dispute this at all. In fact, he opens his response by saying, "yeah," in agreement with the questioner. He does mention that the federal government has slow-walked the creation of its exchange, perhaps in order to encourage states to set up their own, but he doesn’t once raise the possibility that the federal fallback won’t exist at all. Instead, he talks only about the consequences of states declining to establish their own exchanges, not the consequence of what might happen if states decline and the federal government also fails to create an exchange.

Nor does he raise the possibility that the federal government might fail to set up an exchange in the other recording. In that recorded speech, he says that "if your governor doesn't set up an exchange, you're losing hundreds of millions of dollars of tax credits to be delivered to your citizens." Again, he’s not saying, "if your governor doesn’t set up the exchange and the federal government also doesn’t set up an exchange." He’s just saying that this is the result of a state not building its own exchange.

Gruber’s suggestion that he was thinking that the federal government might fail to create an exchange is also odd given that the federal government is required by law to do so if a state does not. Asked about this requirement today by Rep. Justin Amash (R-Mich.), Gruber claimed not to recall the exact details of what the law entails. That’s tough to believe given that Gruber spent years as a high-profile, well-paid consultant to states considering setting up their own exchanges. But even if he does not remember the details now, it is even harder to believe that Gruber did not know about this requirement back in 2012, when he was in the midst of exchange-relaed consulting work for multiple states.
It's hard not to come to the conclusion that he's being deliberately disingenuous.

The most tear jerking moment of the hearing came when Rep. Cynthia Lummis (R-Wyo.) told how her husband's experiences with Obamacare may have contributed to his death from a massive heart attack:
On October 24, the week before election, my husband went to sleep and never woke up. He had a massive heart attack in his sleep at age 65. A perfectly, by all accounts, healthy man. Come to find out, in a conversation with his physician after he died, he chose not to have one of the tests, the last tests, his doctor told him to have. This happened to coincide with the time that we were told that we were not covered by Obamacare. I'm not telling you that my husband died because of Obamacare. He died because he had a massive heart attack in his sleep.
Apparently there was much confusion during his enrollment, and as a result of thinking he was not being covered, he skipped an important test which might have found the problem:


"I want to suggest that regardless of what happened to me personally, that there have been so many glitches in the passage and implementation of Obamacare that have real-life consequences on peoples' lives, " she said, almost choking up. "The so-called glibness that has been referenced today has direct consequences for real American people. So get over your damn glibness."
 Some pre-hearing goodness. The Insiders: The Gruberization of the Democratic Party
It’s too bad the Gruber videos weren’t revealed before the 2014 elections, because they perfectly crystallize the entire Democratic 2014 campaign. That is, don’t admit what you really believe or what you will really do in government. Say things that purposely deceive or at least misdirect the voters from your true intentions. Anyway, Gruber isn’t just a bad episode. He is a living example of what the Democratic Party has become. In its simplest form, Democrats want to talk to the right and then govern to the left. They hide behind platitudes and dishonest attacks on Republicans, but this just doesn’t work, as illustrated by the Democrats’ last gasp in Louisiana this past Saturday, when Senator Mary Landrieu lost her Senate seat to Bill Cassidy, 43 percent to 57 percent.

Despite what is said tomorrow in the House Oversight Committee hearing, perhaps Gruber has already made a lasting contribution to the political vocabulary. If nothing else, he has helped spawn a new verb. As one gentleman wrote in a letter to the editor in The Leaf-Chronicle, “’gruberize’ will now refer to ‘the art of slicking buyers by using catch phrases and weasel wordsmithing.’”
There are a few non-Gruber schadenfreudes, too, but I'll just give them the Paul Caron treatment:

Feds Plan for 35 Agencies to Help Collect, Share, Use Electronic Health Info


Mitch McConnell’s Obamacare gambit: Behind closed doors, Republicans are plotting one last tilt at the Affordable Care Act.

Job health insurance costs rising faster than wages

So Much for the Little Chocolates

Love Magazine has a daily video for Advent. The first, published Dec. 1, stars Miranda Kerr:



Wombat-socho has the original Rule 5 post "Rule 5 Sunday: Relay Breakdown" ready at The Other McCain.

Tuesday, December 9, 2014

Exelon Yields to MDE Extortion

The Maryland Department of the Environment says Exelon Corp. will pay up to $3.5 million to fund more study of the Conowingo power dam's effects on Susquehanna River and Chesapeake Bay water quality.

The agency threatened last month to deny a permit renewal because the Chicago-based company hadn't fully supported its assertion that the dam's reduced ability to trap sediment was harming the Chesapeake Bay, about 10 miles downstream.
. . .
The Army Corps of Engineers has concluded that dredging the river to improve the dam's sediment-trapping ability could cost billions and have relatively little effect on the bay.
The old conventional wisdom was models said that the filling of the pool behind Conowingo Dam was the worst possible thing that could happen to the Bay. The new conventional wisdom is models say that it's not so bad, what we really need to do is stop agriculture in the Chesapeake watershed. I'm sure the truth is somewhere in between.

As Dane-geld goes, 3.5 million isn't all that much. I'm sure Exelon can find a contractor who will get to an answer acceptable to the state for that much.

Wombat's Tuesday News

A selection of stories from Wombat-scocho's "Live at Five: 12.09.14".

“Unconscionable”: Republicans Lash Out Ahead of CIA Report’s Release - The report is out now. It's staggeringly hypocritical for Sen. Feinstein et al. to object to policies she was informed of and supported previously. But this was her last chance to get this shot in for at least two years, and she took it.

Federal Autopsy Released In Michael Brown Shooting - What, Bones and the Jeffersonian weren't available?

Kate Middleton Mistaken For Elsa From “Frozen” At Harlem Childrens’ Center - She's white, she's a princess. Close enough.

Violence Erupts At Berkeley Protests For Second Straight Night - Sure, burn your own house down, but blame someone else when you wind up on the streets or have no nearby store to sell you food.

Administration Unveils Federal Law Enforcement Profiling Ban - New federal policy, profiling is bad, except when its good.

NYT Comes Out Against DiBlasio’s Horse Carriage Ban - What goes unmentioned in this NYT story panning De Blasio's plan, is that his friend and supporter Steve Nislick stands to benefit:
Records show that Steve Nislick, who co-founded the animal-rights group NYCLASS, has ponied up the maximum $4,950 for de Blasio’s campaign. Two other NYCLASS pals, Wendy and John Neu, have chipped in $9,900.

More importantly, the organization has spent $774,000 in ads against a key de Blasio Democratic rival, Christine Quinn.

But this is where it really gets interesting. Because it turns out that this Steve Nislick isn’t just another Greenpeace retread.

At issue here is an entity named Edison Properties, which is, real-estate writer Michael Gross reported in 2009, “a real estate development and management company” that just happens to have two businesses, “Manhattan Mini-Storage and Edison ParkFast — with multiple locations in the same Far West Midtown neighborhood as the stables where the Central Park horses are housed.”

Now, can you guess who is both the CEO of Edison and the man who conjured up the idea of replacing NYC’s horse-drawn carriages with electric cars?

That’s right, Steve Nislick.
Asian Crude Hits Five-Year Low On Oversupply Worries: WTI $62.49, Brent $65.42

Street Artist Sabo Blasts Lena Dunham, Rolling Stone In New Poster - Soft core porn HBO actress Lena Dunham is striving hard to beat Jon Gruber for the worst week award. It seems she claimed to be sorta raped by an Oberlin College Republican named Barry, who had a big mustache and purple boots. And she put it in a book. It turns out there was a college Republican (rare enough) named Barry (also rare) who didn't have a big mustache or purple boots and claims not to have met Lena (lucky him). He's getting ready to sue her, and her publisher, and they are furiously back pedaling, claiming that "Barry" was a pseudonym, and promising to pay his legal costs to date if he'll back off. Which is proof that he shouldn't.



Mark Wahlberg Wants Record Wiped So He Can Join Police Reserve - I covered this a few days ago, but there was no reason given for his pardon request. My opinion remains the same; when the guy he half blinded grows a new eye, give him the pardon.

Wombat-socho has the original Rule 5 post "Rule 5 Sunday: Relay Breakdown" ready at The Other McCain.

Obamacare Schadenfreuede: Gruber in the Hot Seat

Today Dr. Jonathon Gruber faces off with Darryl Issa:

Obamacare architect Jonathan Gruber to feel heat at hearing
Obamacare architect Jonathan Gruber — the gaffe-prone MIT professor who boasted that Democrats purposely deceived the American public about the health care law — is expected to break his silence this morning in a much-anticipated congressional hearing Republicans predict will undo the Affordable Care Act.

“This is the beginning of the unraveling of Obama-care,” U.S. Rep John Mica (R-Fla.) told the Herald. “The hearing clearly will focus on the deception, some of the false information given to both the American public and the Congress in instituting it and getting it passed. ... It may not be the repeal, but the rewriting of it and looking at how we can cover more people with less bureaucracy and less federal mandates.”

Gruber, an MIT economist who also sits on the Massachusetts Health Connector board, and Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services Administrator Marilyn Tavenner are slated to testify at a congressional hearing called “Examining ObamaCare Transparency Failures” before the GOP-led House Oversight and Government Reform Committee today.
I would really rather have Trey Gowdy directing the questioning, but it should still be popcorn worthy.
Democrats, meanwhile, are treating Gruber like political poison. A lawyer for the Obama administration last week asked committee chairman Darrell Issa for Tavenner to testify separately from Gruber, according to a report from Politico. The unusual request suggests the Obama administration is deeply worried about Tavenner and Gruber being photographed sitting side by side.

A spokeswoman for the House committee did not respond to a Herald question about today’s seating arrangement.
They should make them share a love seat.

Gruber to face hostile House panel, tea party ‘I’m with Stupid’ T-shirts
A tea party group said its members will greet Jonathan Gruber, the man at the center of Obamacare’s troubled public image, with T-shirts reading “I’m with Stupid” when he shows up to defend himself Tuesday before what’s likely to be a hostile congressional panel.

Republicans call Mr. Gruber, a professor at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, a key architect of the Affordable Care Act, while Democrats are rushing to put distance between them and their erstwhile star after several rounds of caught-on-tape remarks about the “stupidity of the American voter” and the need to game budget rules to pass Obamacare were made public.

The T-shirts, which were produced by Tea Party Patriots, are another symbol of how controversial Mr. Gruber has become as he prepares to face the House oversight committee.

“With all that’s going on in the Capitol, we didn’t want Mr. Gruber’s curtain call to go unnoticed,” said Jenny Beth Martin, Tea Party Patriots co-founder. “We commemorated his appearance, and in the spirit of the Season, we’d like to offer the Obamacare architect a dozen. He can use them as stocking stuffers for the economically unsophisticated.”
What Jonathan Gruber's Health Care Contracts Tell Us About His Deceptions
Gruber's various health care consulting contracts help shed light on both his influence and the nature of some of his deceptions.

The federal contracts, worth just shy of $400,000, provided access to economic simulations that allowed the bill's authors to perfect—and, one might argue, to game—the law's Congressional Budget Office score.

Gruber misled people about the existence of those contacts even while offering up supportive quotes about the health law in the guise of an independent analyst. When contacted by the media, he declined to disclose his work on the law for the government.
More damningly, when Gruber published an op-ed in The Washington Post at the end of 2009, he was required to submit a disclosure form. The form specifically asked if he had "received any funding, for research or otherwise, from organizations or persons identified in the column." His answer? "No." The Post subsequently published an update.
It's also interesting to compare Gruber's work for the federal government with his work for the states. the thrust of Gruber's most prominent report to the federal government was that Obamacare would lower health premiums. That report was widely cited in the media, as well as by lawmakers, including then House Majority Leader Nancy Pelosi and the White House.

But as Avik Roy pointed out in 2012 at Forbes, Gruber's later reports to states investigating the possibility of setting up health insurance exchanges under the federal law suggested something rather different about how the law would affect premiums. Gruber, Roy wrote, was "quietly telling state governments that the law will significantly increase the cost of insurance." Indeed, in at least one report, produced for the state of Wisconsin, Gruber estimated that for a significant percentage of people, costs would go up even afterthe application of the law's insurance subsidies.

These are the sort of deceptions and misdirections that Gruber described in the wave of videos that were unearthed earlier year: declining to reveal relevant information and switching messages depending on which audience is listening. That's how Gruber sold Obamacare, and it's also how he sold his own work.
OK, it's starting on C-Span. If you don't get C-Span, it's on live here.

Food Abuse



If she wants to play rhythm in a band, she'll need to mike it a little louder.

Wombat-socho has the original Rule 5 post "Rule 5 Sunday: Relay Breakdown" ready at The Other McCain.

Monday, December 8, 2014

Annapolis Pollutes Bay

Wastewater Overflow Reaches Chesapeake Bay
A force main break in Annapolis is fixed but not before thousands of gallons of wastewater overflow reached Chesapeake Bay Saturday.

The Anne Arundel County Department of Public Works said the break was reported around 10:30 Saturday morning on Bay Drive.

It took more than twelve hours before repairs were completed at 11 p.m. Saturday.

The cause of the failed ten-inch pipe was said to be external corrosion.

Crews were able to collect almost 72,000 gallons of wastewater overflow but about 17,000 gallons made its way to the bay.

The DPW says signs have been posted alerting residents.

The area was cleaned and limed, as well, according to the DPW.

The DPW advises people coming in contact with the affected water to wash well with soap and warm water immediately.
Only a few thousand gallon of waste water. Annapolis needs to raise its city taxes and fix it's ailing infrastructure.

Wombat's Monday News Run

A quick romp through the news, as laid out by Wombat-socho in the mostly daily "Live at Five: 12.08.14." Find out what Instapundit is going to quip about before he quips about it.

Thirteen Killed In Failed Yemen Raid: Two hostages killed by Al Qaeda captors - Of course, you probably heard about this already. All we can do is try, and when they're threatening imminent death it's time to move. I hear Al Queda paid a price; 13 dead. You can see the results of their efforts at the Jawa's hut. Warning: Gruesome. Justice Served
When the levee breaks, mama, you got to move

Typhoon Hagupit Hits The Philippines - 21 Dead and counting, 900,000 people had to evacuate their homes. We should grateful we had a relatively uneventful hurricane season for the US.

Ebola Czar Klain Leaving Post In March - Wow, that was fast. Once it's out of the news, who cares?

Protesters Smash Windows, Shut Down Highway In Berkeley - If I didn't have an uncle who lives in Berkeley (we think), I'd be just as happy if they burned it down. Shit in your own nest, suckers.

Emily Deschanel Preggers - Congratulations to a previous Rule 5 winner, even if she had to share it with her sister. Although, I do have a bone to pick with her regarding her portrayal of scientists.

Rolling Stone Admits Problems With UVA Story Were Its Fault - The case of the violent gang rape by a fraternity at UVA is a prime example of how little liberals care for the truth. They're all but insisting that the facts don't matter, it's what they want to say that matters.

Obama Tells BET Audience Despite Grand Jury Verdicts, Things Are Better - But the nation thinks things are worse. Mission Accomplished!

Norks Deny “Righteous” Hack Attack On Sony - If Kim Jung Un told me the sky was blue I'd have it independently verified. That pox on the earth can't go a way fast enough. But to be fair, Sony wouldn't put out a comedy about the assassination of Preznit Obama. The film about the assassination of President Bush won awards.

Amanda Bynes Looks Healthy, Trim In New Twitter Photo - I hope she's on the road to recovery. But these things never go smoothly.

Hefner Responds To Allegations In Wake Of Cosby Lawsuit: “I Would Never Tolerate This Kind Of Behavior”  - Of course, Hugh was willing to pay market rates.

Mexico Says Evidence Proves Missing Students Were Incinerated - Making "The Bridge" look like an understatement. I had a Mexican friend, a fellow graduate student who was very concerned about the direction Mexico was going. He died in a traffic accident in Tijuana.

Loose Endz: Thou Shalt Not Cook Thy Neighbor - I wish I hadn't read this, but she clearly wins Floron of the Year - 2013 contest. White people aren't meant to live in Florida, the sun depletes their folic acid and drives them crazy.

Jammie Wearing Fools: MSNBC 2011 – Delusional Tea Party Could Become Violent; MSNBC 2014 – Arson, Looting “Not Necessarily Violence” - Foolish consistency is the hob-goblin of little minds. I'm still rooting for the post Ferguson violence to burn down the MSNBC studio in New York.

The Lonely Conservative: After Years Of Inflicting Heartburn On All Of Us, Obama Diagnosed With Acid Reflux - Fortunately for me, it has a pretty simple cure.

Weasel Zippers: Obamacare Architect Jonathan Gruber – Abortion Of “Marginal Children” A “Social Good” - I prefer to think of them as voters.

Wombat-socho has the original Rule 5 post "Rule 5 Sunday: Relay Breakdown" ready at The Other McCain.

Persistent Obamacare Schadenfreude

No matter how much I beat it down, it keeps creeping out:

Guess who's going to Congress?  Dr. Gruber! Congressional Republicans to grill Obamacare consultant at hearing
Issa said the public deserved an explanation from Gruber at Tuesday's hearing.

"If you can't trust what he says, and what he says he'll do, to get votes and trick the American people into voting for something, then can you trust his analytics?" Issa said of Gruber.

"It is our job to see that the administration is working to run the country and that they are reporting honestly their successes and their failures,” he told Reuters.

Republicans say Gruber's comments show the administration deceived Americans as it pushed the law through Congress. Americans For Prosperity, a group backed by the billionaire Koch brothers, used Gruber's comments to attack Democrat Mary Landrieu in the runoff for the Louisiana Senate race.

Democrats have distanced themselves from Gruber. Obama referred to him as "some adviser who never worked on our staff" who "expressed an opinion that I completely disagree with."
Issa's democratic opponent on the panel promised to waste more time deflecting criticism of Obamacare:
Representative Elijah Cummings, the top Democrat on the House Oversight panel, called Gruber's comments "very unfortunate." He said he would use the hearing to talk about the benefits of Obamacare.

"To spend hours upon hours of time trying to get (Gruber) to explain himself, to me it does not insure one more person, it does not help heal anybody, and it doesn't do anybody any good. We're wasting our time," Cummings said.
Will Jonathan Gruber Topple Obamacare? The health economist’s controversial remarks could undo him and the law he worked so hard to create.
For just about everyone else who has dealt with Gruber, though—Democrats, academics, policy wonks, and the health care reporters who used to call him regularly for catchy quotes about what the latest Obamacare development really means—the videos are just head-scratchers. He’s a smart guy, everyone says, and he has been a hugely successful economist who clearly knows his health care policy. So they’re all coming back to the same question: Why the hell would he say that? Does he really believe it?

The answer, according to the people who know Gruber best, is that he has always been someone who is two seconds away from putting his foot in his mouth. Yes, he has had an astonishing rise in the world of health care policy—and it’s completely deserved, in their view, because of his groundbreaking work on predicting the cost impact of different kinds of health care legislation. Gruber is the man who developed an economic model that could basically work like a faster Congressional Budget Office—a huge help to congressional staffers as they drafted the Affordable Care Act, as well as the Massachusetts policymakers who wrote Mitt Romney’s health care reform law that preceded it.

But politically savvy? No, no, no. Gruber is a chatty, affable guy, but he’s also a man with no filter—and he knows it. It’s always when he drifts away from economics, and tries to talk about politics, that he gets into trouble, colleagues say. That’s where Gruber stepped on so many land mines in those videos—claiming there was a strategy to hide uncomfortable details from voters, as if he knew the political strategy and not just the economics, and that the “stupidity of the American voter” allowed them to get away with it.
So his appearance before Congress should be some good TV. Stay tuned!

Half of the Senators who voted for Obamacare won't be part of new Senate
To be sure, it isn’t fair to attribute all of the turnover in the chamber to Obamacare. In some cases — such as John Kerry leaving his seat to become secretary of state, or Robert Byrd passing away — Obamacare clearly had nothing to do with the departures. Additionally, some outgoing pro-Obamacare votes were replaced by new Democratic senators (although that tended to be the case in heavily Democratic states).

That having been said, many senators who voted for Obamacare lost re-election battles in which they were hit hard for their support for the law and other Democrats were forced to retire because they had no hope of getting re-elected given their support for the law. A total of 16 Senators who voted for Obamacare either failed to win reelection or declined to run for reelection and had their seats turned over to Republicans.
Lost and replaced by a Republican:

Sen. Mark Begich, D-Alaska, Sen. Mark Pryor, D-Ark., Sen. Mark Udall, D-Colo., Sen. Kay Hagan, D-N.C., Sen. Mary Landrieu, D-La., Russ Feingold, D-Wis., Blanche Lincoln, D-Ark., Arlen Specter, D-Penn.

Left Senate and replaced by a Republican:

Jay Rockefeller, D-W.V., Max Baucus, D-Mont., Tim Johnson, D-S.D., Tom Harkin, D-Iowa, Ben Nelson, D-Neb., Byron Dorgan, D-N.D., Evan Bayh, D-Ind., Roland Burris, D-Ill.
. . .As you sow, so shall you reap.

Health law impacts primary care doc shortage
A survey this year by The Physicians Foundation found that 81 percent of doctors describe themselves as either over-extended or at full capacity, and 44 percent said they planned to cut back on the number of patients they see, retire, work part-time or close their practice to new patients.

At the same time, insurance companies have routinely limited the number of doctors and providers on their plans as a way to cut costs. The result has further restricted some patients' ability to get appointments quickly.

One purpose of the new health law was connecting patients, many of whom never had insurance before, with primary care doctors to prevent them from landing in the emergency room when they are sicker and their care is more expensive. Yet nearly 1 in 5 Americans lives in a region designated as having a shortage of primary care physicians, and the number of doctors entering the field isn't expected to keep pace with demand.

The Association of American Medical Colleges projects the shortage will grow to about 66,000 in little more than a decade as fewer residency slots are available and as more medical students choose higher-paying specialty areas.
You could call this an unexpected, unintended consequence of Obamacare, except that conservatives predicted it would have this effect over and over as the law was being rammed through without their votes.

Some background on the King vs Burwell suit which may drive a stake through the liver of Obamacare. Pessimist's persistence could pay off against Obamacare
The legal argument was fleshed out early in 2011 by Jonathan Adler, a law professor at Case Western Reserve University. Asked to write a paper for a University of Kansas School of Law conference, he read the 906-page law, "which it's clear a lot of people didn't do." He concluded that tax credits were dangled as an incentive for states to create the online exchanges, which administration and congressional proponents deny.

Then Michael Cannon, a health policy economist at the libertarian Cato Institute, discovered that the Internal Revenue Service was preparing regulations that would allow tax credits in federal as well as state exchanges. That, he said, was not the letter of the law.

The 6 AM Flex



Wombat-socho has the original Rule 5 post "Rule 5 Sunday: Relay Breakdown" ready at The Other McCain.

Sunday, December 7, 2014

Redskins Attempt to Take on Sheep

The now ridiculously bad Washington Redskins (3-9) are taking on the St. Louis Rams (5-7) at 1 PM in Landover Summerfield, Maryland, a small town conveniently located outside of Washington D.C. on the deservedly infamous Washington beltway. The Rams were my original "home town" team growing up, in their Los Angeles days. I even named a fish after one of their players, Deacon Jones. The fish was a nasty Jack Dempsey with the habit of beating up other fish in my cichlid tank, and taking away their food (goldfish). But I haven't followed the Rams for a long time, so I'll save my little remaining optimism for the 'Skins.

The liberal war on football appears to have ended for the time being, as the focus has shifted off attacking men through athletics, and attacking them through the university fraternity system instead. But that's not a fit subject for this post, so on with football.

It rather appears the Redskin's quarterback Robert Griffin III has decided he'd rather walk without crutches for the rest of his life than be the quarterback the Redskins need to win (if that's even possible): TMZ, Citing Unnamed Redskins Player: ‘Playing with RG3 Has Been a Nightmare’


So, TMZ Sports is getting a piece of the unnamed Redskins sources action.

Either late Friday night or early Saturday morning — depending on how you look at it — TMZ published a report, citing a player “who spoke with us on the condition of anonymity,” alleging no one in the Redskins locker room believes in Robert Griffin III anymore.

The player — who spoke with us on the condition of anonymity — says playing with RG3 has been a nightmare this season … and the locker room has lost faith in the QB.

“No one is happy … no one gets the hype around him anymore,” the player source told TMZ.

But it’s not so much what Griffin does (or doesn’t do) on the field, but rather how he behaves off it that has his teammates bothered, according to TMZ.
“He’s secluded and it affects us in the game,” the source told TMZ. “We don’t have that real rapport. He’s lost confidence and is complacent now.”
That player source had one final dagger to weave in.

“I don’t see him being in the NFL for that long,” he who shall remain unnamed told TMZ. “I think he goes into politics. He’s good at that kinda thing.”
A politician? Washington D.C. could do worse. In fact, it has repeatedly.

Enjoy the game, or a game or two.

UPDATE: The Redskins lost 0-24. Do they understand that in order to win, they need to score?

Wombat-socho has the original Rule 5 post "Rule 5 Sunday: Relay Breakdown" ready at The Other McCain.

Pearl Harbor Day

Selections from Georgia's father, Vincent Massei's personal log and some annotated photos from his service in the Pacific:



And a little WWII Rule 5:


The Twin Fantasy?

Or is it a nightmare. You be the judge:



Wombat-socho has the original Rule 5 post "Rule 5 Sunday: Relay Breakdown" ready at The Other McCain.

Drone Eels, the Wave of Future?

Why Eel Drones Are the Future of Naval Warfare
In the decade ahead, unmanned underwater vehicles, or UUVs, may have the same sort of disruptive effects on militaries as their flying counterparts. More than 12 countries are at work on undersea robots, which some militaries, including the United States, use to check for mines, map the sea floor and collect weather data. There’s no reason they couldn’t be used to defend battleships from small boats or even carry out attacks on enemy divers. But what will they look like? A team of researchers from Singapore led by Jianxin Xu recently debuted a robotic eel design prototype that could signal the future of undersea warfare.
US Navy’s Eel Robot

“Anguilliform [eel like] fish consume less energy when on a long distance journey than regular autonomous underwater vehicles,” Xu told Defense One. “They are highly maneuverable and flexible, making them more suitable than Gliders for navigating small spaces… The noiseless propulsion is another advantage” for the military, he says. “They’re less detectable than robot subs that propel themselves the same way as conventional subs.”

Xu’s design represents a breakthrough robotic fish that effectively mimic the rather unique way that eels and other anguilliform fish swim. His paper describing the prototype and all the software that went into making it work, was published in the most recent issue of the Unmanned Systems journal. But while it’s close to nature, it’s not the first robotic fish or even the first robotic eel. The U.S. Office of Naval Research and the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency have explored designs that look like actual sea life, such as robotic jellyfish, manta rays, tuna and eels for years.
I wonder if robot eel are as good a bait for Striped Bass as live ells?

Robot jellyfish