In a recent landmark case, a federal jury found the University of Maryland was “deliberately indifferent” to the sex-based harassment of a male student after he was cleared of sexual misconduct allegations. A scholar says this first-of-its-kind ruling reflects a “long-standing” issue of bias on college campuses.
The male student, who filed under the pseudonym John Doe, was one of two men accused of rape by a female peer in October 2020. After a lengthy investigation and a five-day hearing, an officer found both men not responsible, according to the ruling.
The officer concluded that the accuser’s credibility was “significantly undermined” and that forensic testing contradicted her claims. She did not appeal the decision.
Despite Doe being cleared, accuser Jane Roe and the campus group Preventing Sexual Assault began targeting Doe. They publicly labeled him a rapist who was “under investigation,” causing him to be disinvited from social events.
At a PSA “Real Talk” event, Roe named Doe as one of her rapists and described the alleged incident in detail. She also approached his friends to call him a rapist. One PSA member posted multiple times about him on a messaging board called Yik Yak, including a post calling him a “sexual predator.” Roe referenced him in a campus journal interview about sexual assault. PSA also pressured the lacrosse club’s leadership to remove Doe, claiming he had raped Roe and that the Office of Civil Rights and Sexual Misconduct had mishandled the case.
Doe filed a complaint with OCRSM, which was dismissed after winter break. Officials said there was “no evidence that [Roe] directly communicated anything to the UMD Club Lacrosse that would entail excluding you from any of its programs or activities” and that the allegations did not meet the policy definition of retaliation.
However, the harassment continued. When OCRSM informed both PSA and Club Lacrosse that they could not remove Doe based on allegations for which he was found not responsible, PSA suggested they find “a way to really just make [Doe] feel unwelcome enough that he doesn’t want to come around anyway.”
The Lacrosse Club president ultimately removed Doe from the club. He told Kurt Klier, the university’s director of club sports, that they needed to be “very careful with what we say to [PSA Defendants], as they spread information very quickly and can single handedly ruin our reputation if we don’t do what they want to see us do.”
Doe then filed a second complaint with OCRSM, to which he never received a response. He formally sued the university in April 2022.
The jury found the university liable for “deliberate indifference” under Title IX after determining that Doe was subjected to harassment on the basis of his sex and that it was severe enough to deprive him of an educational opportunity or benefit.
To prove “deliberate indifference” under Title IX, Doe had to show that he faced sex-based harassment, that the harassment was severe and pervasive enough to deny him equal access to educational opportunities, and that the university could be held responsible for it.
The jury answered yes to all questions.
While the original lawsuit sought $10 million in damages, Doe was ultimately awarded $1 in nominal damages.
They should have awarded him at least a million. I would gladly contribute my 33 cents. He should also go after some of them personally for slander and libel.
Insty at his substack, has a candidate for Word of the Year: Oikicide, "It’s happening all over the West. Here’s the word for it." "Oikicide, as I mean it, is the deliberate eradication (or attempt at same) of one’s own people and culture. (There’s a narrower ancient Greek meaning, about the destruction of a specific home and family, but that’s not what I mean.)" Dan McCarthy at the Chronic argues The Tamed Liberal West Doesn’t Understand the Threat of Islam.
Stephen Kruiser at PJM thinks It's Tempting to Grab a Tinfoil Hat During an Avalanche of Outages. Gina Milan@ginamilan_, "25 things the Biden administration spent your tax dollars on instead of updating FAA equipment: 1. $27 billion EPA Greenhouse Gas Reduction Fund (“gold bars”) rushed to NGOs with political ties and almost no track record. 2. $7.5 billion for EV chargers under NEVI that produced only a few hundred operational stations. 3. $7 billion Solar for All program with layers of pass-through middlemen. 4. $2.05 billion in NSF grants that prioritized DEI over scientific merit. 5. $15.5 billion to push electric vehicles...." Ace cites the WSJ: Network Outages Are a "Bugmaggeddon" Caused by AI Tools Used by Hackers? "Before getting to that article -- which is a confusing mess, honestly -- let me quote this tweet from Nicole Perlroth, which explains her theory clearly. According to her read on the situation, AI hacking tools are finding and exploiting vulnerabilities so quickly that programmers are forced to rush "fixes" to the system, including AI-written code fixes, that haven't had time to be fully vetted and tested."
At the Daily Californican, John Yoo, law professor and author of ‘Torture Memos,’ to leave UC Berkeley “I am sorry, however, that my departure will reduce the number of conservative professors in public law at Berkeley by 100 percent,” Yoo said in the email. “I hope that the university will take this as an opportunity to consider that the notion of diversity should, most importantly, include ideology, not just the usual race, gender, and economic categories that my colleagues usually mean by diversity.”
From Campus Reform, Protesters disrupt former Border Patrol chief's Rutgers speech. "Protesters temporarily forced former Border Patrol commander Gregory Bovino offstage during a Rutgers Republicans event, but he returned to finish his speech after police intervened."
A COMPLAINT MADE against an ad for a Bare by Vogue tanning product, posted by an influencer on Instagram, has been upheld by the Advertising Standards Authority (ASA). Bare by Vogue is a popular tanning brand established by Irish presenter and media personality Vogue Williams. Williams is co-host of the podcast My Therapist Ghosted Me with comedian Joanne McNally. The Dubliner launched the brand in 2019. It regularly gifts influencers with products as part of its marketing, and pays influencers to advertise the company’s products on social media.
The complaint centred on an ad posted by chef Trisha Lewis, who has over 288,000 followers on Instagram. Lewis had posted three images of her wearing and applying the tan to her Instagram story. She had linked the brand’s website in the post and included an affiliate discount code.
The ASA stated that the complainant had highlighted that Lewis had used the ‘Paris’ filter on three images, which adds warmth to the image.
Known as Manu La Porta, my name is Emanuele, known for the famous quote “Bom dia” on my Instagram page.
Currently one of the most followed kite and wing athletes and influencers in the americas, I started water sports when I was 10, sailing optimists. My father’s love and passion for water sports brought me to kiteboarding and the rest is history. I’ve build my life and career kiteboarding and Wingfoiling and plan to do it for a long time!
Something a little different today. Yesterday, seeking shelter from the wind, Pete fished the Potomac River, and had miles and miles of fish under birds.
So we went back there today, launching at Abell's Wharf on Breton Bay
A little fall color from the river.
We were out by sunrise.
"You shoulda been here yesterday." We did find fish under birds, but not miles and miles of them. A few birds would accumulate over some fish, and if you ran to them quickly enough you could catch a few.
Jim, a newbie to Pete's boat with one of the better fish. Most were in the slot, near the upper end, with a few unders, and a few overs.